Saxton Comments Analysis

Quantitative

Saxton Field is a jointly-owned and funded regional sport and recreation facility benefiting the residents of Nelson and Tasman District. You can take part in a broad range of activities at Saxton Field including cricket, athletics, soccer, hockey, softball, archery and netball among others. Is this comment related to Saxton or Saxtons Field? Does the comment discuss Saxton Field or Saxtons Area?

38 comments were found to be true for the question "Saxton Field is a jointly-owned and funded regional sport and recreation facility benefiting the residents of Nelson and Tasman District. You can take part in a broad range of activities at Saxton Field including cricket, athletics, soccer, hockey, softball, archery and netball among others. Is this comment related to Saxton or Saxtons Field? Does the comment discuss Saxton Field or Saxtons Area?".

Qualitative

Please provide a comprehensive report of the comments that discuss Saxton. Include an abstractive summary of the comments, and key themes. Please include a section regarding Active Recreation with reasons supporting or opposing.

38 comments were used to answer the question "Please provide a comprehensive report of the comments that discuss Saxton. Include an abstractive summary of the comments, and key themes. Please include a section regarding Active Recreation with reasons supporting or opposing.".

Response

Comprehensive Report on Comments Discussing Saxton Field

Overview

From a total of 2877 comments analyzed, 38 comments specifically discussed Saxton Field. These comments provided insights into various aspects of the field, including proposed developments, community needs, and the importance of inclusive recreational spaces.

Summary of Comments

The comments largely support the development and enhancement of Saxton Field, emphasizing its role as a central hub for sports and recreation in the Nelson and Tasman Districts. Key proposals include the installation of all-weather sports turf, the development of inclusive play spaces, and improvements to existing facilities to cater to a broader range of community needs, including those of disabled individuals.

Key Themes

  1. Inclusive Play Spaces: Several comments highlighted the need for inclusive play areas that cater to children with disabilities. The community expressed strong support for creating environments where children of all abilities can play together safely and inclusively.

  2. All-Weather Sports Turf: There is significant support for the installation of all-weather sports turf at Saxton Field. Proponents argue that this would allow for year-round sports activities, reduce maintenance costs, and attract more sports events to the region, which could boost local economy.

  3. Community Engagement and Support: Comments reflect a strong community interest in participating in and supporting the development of Saxton Field. There is a notable emphasis on volunteer involvement and the benefits of community-driven initiatives.

  4. Accessibility and Safety: Enhancing accessibility for all, including adequate lighting, safe pathways, and accessible facilities, was a recurring theme. There is a call for regular audits to ensure that the park meets disability standards and remains safe and welcoming for all users.

Active Recreation

The comments provide several reasons supporting the focus on active recreation at Saxton Field:

  • Health and Wellbeing: Active recreation facilities contribute significantly to the physical and mental health of the community. Facilities like all-weather turf and inclusive play areas encourage more people to engage in physical activities.

  • Economic Benefits: Developing Saxton Field as a sports hub can attract regional sports tournaments and events, boosting local tourism and providing economic benefits to the area.

  • Community Cohesion: Sports and recreational activities are seen as vital for fostering community spirit and engagement. Enhancing these facilities at Saxton Field would provide a common ground for residents to come together, promoting social cohesion.

  • Inclusivity: There is a strong community drive towards inclusivity in recreational activities, ensuring that facilities are accessible to individuals of all abilities, which aligns with broader social values of equality and participation.

Conclusion

The community feedback on Saxton Field is overwhelmingly positive, with a strong emphasis on inclusivity, community involvement, and the health benefits of active recreation. The proposed developments not only aim to enhance the physical infrastructure but also seek to foster a more inclusive and engaged community. The council is encouraged to consider these insights in their planning and development strategies for Saxton Field.

Comments

Point ID Name Option_Selected Comment
1445.2 Iain Sheves for Wakatu Incorporation None The comment submitted by Wakatū Incorporation addresses several key points regarding their relationship with the land and their role as kaitiaki (guardians). They emphasize their deep-rooted connection to their ancestral lands and waters, which are seen as an indivisible whole, crucial to their identity and responsibilities across generations. This connection is underpinned by their whakapapa (genealogy) and the spiritual and physical bonds that tie them to the land and water.

Wakatū Incorporation expresses concerns about the Nelson City Council's Long Term Plan (LTP) for 2024-2034, particularly noting the absence of reference to Te Tiriti o Waitangi/The Treaty of Waitangi and the principles it upholds. They stress the importance of these principles in the governance and management of local council affairs, especially in recognizing and supporting the role of Māori and mana whenua in local decision-making processes.

The submission highlights the disappointment with the LTP's lack of detail on promoting partnership and participation of iwi, mana whenua, and Māori entities in decision-making processes. Wakatū Incorporation calls for a greater commitment from the Council to uphold Te Tiriti and to develop strategic plans that include measurable outcomes to ensure sustainable management of natural resources in accordance with Te Tiriti principles.

Overall, the comment from Wakatū Incorporation is a call to action for the Nelson City Council to recognize and integrate the values and principles of Te Tiriti o Waitangi into their planning and operations, ensuring that the rights and responsibilities of Māori and mana whenua are adequately represented and respected in local governance.
576.2 Adele Fitzpatrick for Museums Aotearoa None The comment does not mention Saxton Field or Saxtons Area. It focuses entirely on the Founders Heritage Park Reorganisation Project and issues related to the Nelson City Council's handling of heritage and museum matters. There is no discussion of Saxton Field or any sports and recreation activities associated with it.
1005.3 Jud Hadfield for The Sandpit Incorporated None The comment mentions Saxton Field specifically in relation to the proposal for a new beach sports facility. The proposed location for this facility is Two Oaks Green at Saxton Fields, which is described as an ideal location due to its flat terrain, sufficient parking, central location, and existing recognition as a sports venue with public transport access. The area is currently set up as a soccer field but is noted to be rarely used, regardless of the season. This information directly relates to Saxton Field as the proposed site for the new development.
1066.8 Jane du Feu for Te Tau Ihu o Te Waka Māori Cultural Council None The comment mentions Saxton Field as one of the potential venues for hosting Te Matatini, a significant cultural event. It is listed alongside Trafalgar Park and Neale Park as options for the location of this event. The decision on the venue will be made by the Te Matatini Board.
950.2 Bianca and Andy Farmer None Bianca Farmer expresses strong support for the inclusive play space planned for Saxton Field, emphasizing its importance for her son with a rare chromosome deletion and severe delays, who uses a wheelchair. She highlights the challenges of finding suitable play spaces where her son can actively participate with his sister, underscoring the joy and inclusivity such spaces bring. Farmer details past positive experiences with inclusive playground equipment in Brightwater and stresses the importance of simple accessibility features like wheelchair-friendly pathways. She advocates for consultation with the disability community to ensure playgrounds meet diverse needs and insists on maintaining allocated funding to ensure the project's feasibility. Farmer also notes the broader impact on the disability community in Nelson and Tasman District, emphasizing the overwhelming challenges these families face, which often prevent them from participating in public consultations. She concludes by urging consideration of these factors in decision-making about the play space.
1236.5 J Duncan None The comment does not discuss Saxton Field or Saxtons Area. It focuses entirely on the proposed subdivision in the Maitai Valley, expressing opposition to the development and its potential impacts on the environment, traffic, and local community. The commenter requests the protection of the existing rural zoning and prioritization of other identified areas for housing development.
560.2 Rowan Hick None I would like to make a submission about the Forestry long term plan with Ngāti Koata : 
 
"Thank you for moving here, the town needs more like you". 
 
I moved to Nelson with my partner after having enjoyed the trails with a good friend who'd moved here 3 years earlier. For people such as myself MTB is a lifestyle 'hobby'. I've been privvy to 2 other regions in NZ where both access has been progressively eroded (Woodhill) and where access has been maintained and enhanced (Whakarewarewa). The difference could not be starker between the two. 
 
Rotorua from where I grew up (Whakatane) had been very depressed, through tourism and mountain biking activities has greatly influenced the town. MTB'ers from all over NZ and around the world travel to Rotorua as a world class destination. MTBers are good for the town - spending money on accommodation/food/entertainment when not out riding. Partners and families spend when their other halves are riding. Through Covid it anecdotally kept the town alive, you'd go down for a weekend and there would be thousands of riders. 
 
This has only come about because of Rotorua Trails Trust and the partnership with the local iwi. Further facilities and employment opportunities for the town grow out of it as a result. Across 10 years of riding in Rotorua it was amazing to see what was springing up as a direct result of MTB’ing (Ride Rotorua, new shuttle service, second parking area, trails being built, hot tub facilities)
 
People enjoy going to Rotorua. Woodhill by the other token has become a less attractive proposition - continual fee hikes, erosion of facilities and general traffic woes literally was the deciding factor for us leaving Auckland. It was no longer enjoyable to drive 2-2.5 hours , for 2 hours of ride time, on the same trails over and over. Not one person I talk to enjoys Woodhill. 
 
Nelson has the best trails in the country. I've ridden in NZ, Canada, USA, Peru. Nelson is a world class destination - with trails that you can finish on, and in 5minutes be at the Freehouse. It's home base for epic week of riding - you can do local trails, go to the Gorge, and do the Old Ghost Road. 
 
There's mountain bikes everywhere, this city has an incredible (visible) ratio of bikes per capita. On the trails you'll hear accents from different lands constantly, either Australians on school holidays or someone out from the States. Every one of those riders have come here for the trails, and you know everyone on of them is spending an easy $2000/week here (I wouldn't be surprised on average more like $4-5000/week). That's all money injected into the local economy. 
 
If Nelson loses the majority of it's trail network people like me would not move here, kids will get bored, the town will lose out on tourism revenue & resulting employment opportunities. The list goes on. Moreover I think it would be also create a divide in the community in a time, where bridges have been built and need to be maintained. People have spent untold volunteer hours building the network, along with fees to gain access. To that have that removed I imagine would be a very bitter pill.  

Given discussions as I understand it have been ongoing since 2020, I don't think both sides understand how important this is to the town. It's hard to imagine if you're not a mountain biker, but if you are, it's quite clear to see, Nelson is one of a short list on the worlds MTB'ing hotspot destinations. 
 
"Thank you for moving here, the town needs more like you". 
 
I go back to this comment, this is by one of the local business owners of a notable business I had on Sunday. He told me this at the local 'Cars and Coffee' meetup - as I've got a software startup that I'm building here, we were featured on an international podcast and he heard me mention I was based in Nelson. His words were (paraphrasing) "We need tech companies like yourselves here to give our young people opportunities and something to lookup to outside of the usual employment paths" 
 
So there's a direct example of 'Nelson's MTB scene leading to someone moving towns, bringing their business with them, and hopefully providing employment opportunities in the future'
1057.15 Cameron Carter None Summary of key points in my submission. Please see my supporting document for full details




Topic
Submission or request




NCC Climate strategy
Incorporate key elements of the council’s climate strategy into the LTP. These should include the following:
·        Adopt a target for reductions in regional carbon emissions of at least 7% per year from 2024 through 2030
·        Report quarterly on progress towards meeting this target
·        Establish a contingency fund for additional climate measures identified in the NCC climate strategy
·        Add a statement on how the Council will respond to future sea level rise, specifically which areas will it protect and where will it retreat, and make allowance for the costs of these choices
·        Integrate climate strategy as part of the next LTP in 2027
·        Acknowledge that climate change appears to be occurring faster, with more damaging impacts, than previously understood
·        Start a discussion with the Nelson community about targeted rates to pay for flood protection in higher risk areas.


Transport
Support the East-West corridor for cycling
Support New bus hub at Millers Acre
Support Safer speeds around Stoke School
Support The ‘Bridge to Better’ urban revitalisation project
Support Improving the St Vincent St cycle facility
Support Intersection and roundabout safety treatments
Support Car-sharing initiative
Allocate future funding for new buses to cater for higher patronage
Investigate a) the use of congestion charging, b) Active Travel plans for NCC staff, c) replacing NCC vehicles with EVs, and d) providing “bus only” lanes at key intersections.


Solid waste
Support a household food waste collection service
Invest increased revenue from landfill levy into developing a distributed, community-led service to reduce waste from landfill
Include community/business expertise, including NTCF, on the group developing the Joint Waste Management and Minimisation Plan
Apply for MFE funding to implement a food scrap collection and processing system
Work with other councils to advocate for a national container returns scheme
Allocate funds to plan for and manage the waste from emergency events such as floods, earthquakes.


Property buyout
Support Option 2 - Accept the Government’s offer of financial assistance and apply the Council’s draft eligibility principles, while urging the Government to amend criteria for EQC payouts.


Forestry
Support Option 2 - Exit commercial forestry over time and grow a continuous canopy of mixed species.


Housing Reserve Fund
Support Option 2 - Broaden the purpose of the Housing Reserve Fund and work with partners to deliver social and affordable housing.
Amend criteria for new applications to require alignment with the Urban Greening Plan 2022.


Artificial turf
Support Option 1 - Retain current approach of continuing to improve existing sports fields.


Nature and climate
Allocate funds for a review of the Biodiversity Strategy and development of a Biodiversity Plan, both in conjunction with the Tasman District Council
Allocate funds for implementation of the Urban Greening Plan 2022.


Economic
Require those seeking Major Events funding to identify the carbon footprint of the event and indicate how these will be minimised
Require events on Council land, or receiving funding from Council or its related entities, to have a waste minimisation plan.


Corporate
Support development of the Climate Strategy and update of the Climate Action Plan.


Funding for NTCF
Allocate funding of $155,076 for the Nelson Tasman Climate Forum for 2024-25 and subsequent years (adjusted for inflation).


Mountain biking trail access
Recommend for NCC to prioritise negotiating a long-term access plan with Ngāti Koata.
887.33 Hana Wilkinson for National Public Health Service None As mentioned in our submission to the 2021-2031 LTP, NPHS Te 
Waipounamu recommends that future reviews of reserves policies 
include all of the alcohol control and the smoke and vape free polices 
contained in the Saxton Field Reserves management plan to ensure 
consistency across the region. It may also be included in the general 
policies that are being developed as outlined on pg 8.
NPHS Te Waipounamu recommends utilising an audit tool (such as 
PARCs20) for assessing whether parks are meeting disability standards 
be utilised to ensure accessibility. The PARC tool was developed in 
collaboration with Hutt, Porirua and Wellington city councils, CCS 
Disability Action and the New Zealand Blind Foundation. The tool 
evaluates the accessibility, usability and safety of (a) routes and (b) 
facilities and amenities. The accessible routes section includes: (i) 
accessible parking spaces and (ii) path surfaces. The facilities and 
amenities encompass: (i) play areas including play richness, (ii) rest 
areas (iii) toilets and (iv) drinking fountains. Using such a tool to audit 
would identify where there are barriers (damaged footpaths, 
inaccessible playgrounds, toilets and seating) for people to use the 
spaces. In addition to above, audits should also review: 

Space for pump tracks, bike jumps
Appropriate seating and picnic tables
Community garden areas to support access to healthy food
Outdoor art features and murals
Fruit trees to support access to healthy food
Native plants and trees to support shading, biodiversity, flood
protection and carbon sequestration
Covered bike stands
Adequate lighting for safety
Updating outdated facilities
Paths and connectivity to walking and cycling networks
Signage/ wayfinding – appropriate for low vision blind
Waste management – recycling bins etc


 
An audit would highlight gaps and support prioritisation of upgrades.
We
recommend investment into the above amenities as this will have health
and environmental co-benefits and increase the number of people using
these spaces.

Involving the community in volunteering initiatives such as planting trees
and weed control could also be a way of supplementing necessary
projects. Ecological restoration programs have the potential to enhance
people’s wellbeing if designed in ways that intentionally enable health
and wellbeing benefits through access to fresh air, space to move,
engagement with nature, and opportunities for genuine social
connection, sense of achievement and optimism for the future.21 It was
noted that the priorities outlined on pg 87 do not seem to fully align with
the specific projects/actions proposed directly below. It is understood
that making parks and facilities more accessible will be tied in with the
accessibility audit mentioned earlier in the Draft Activities Summaries
LTP 2024-2034 (pg 79).
Recommend involving community volunteers more in
the management of parks and reserves such as tree
planting and weed control.
-Increase the awareness and opportunities for people to
volunteer particularly younger people.
- provide resources for communities to deliver on their
neighbourhood's aspirations in council reserves.
24.2 Nicki and Halena Berkett None An inclusive play space is desperately needed in our region & Saxtons Field would be the perfect central location for one to be built.
An inclusive play space would be an amazing community facility, a destination for many families & a dream come true for some.
Hundreds of families in Nelson can not access a suitable & safe play space for their children. To have a fenced play space suitable for wheelchairs, walkers & pushchairs would mean so many would be able to safely enjoy time out in the fresh air, children could exercise, gain skills & confidence. Parents, grandparents & carers could relax & relish the experience, (Instead of constantly being on guard, or assisting their child).
An inclusive play space would give families for the first time an opportunity where all siblings & whanau could safely play together. Where children & young adults of all abilities could finally have a place to go & really have fun. Not just watch from the sidelines or have one piece of equipment accessible to them.
Saxtons walking tracks & fields are extensively used by walkers, runners, bikers & families, an inclusive play space would be an awesome addition to this facility & our community.
I have been chatting to the park users, young & old for the last 3 months about this & there is a huge level of interest & excitement in the proposed project.
On a personal note we live in Saxtons area with our daughter who is a wheelchair user. We have three grandchildren who all adore going to the park on a weekly basis with us. Halena mainly watches them from the path as she cannot access any of the playground equipment. She can enjoy one basket swing with her nieces & nephew in Mako Street. (photo attached). But to get to it she has to crawl through the industrial sized bark, often getting splinters in her hands & tearing her pants. As you can see by the photos that this is well worth the effort to enjoy special moments like these. Imagine if she had the opportunity every week to share their play, easily, safely & with dignity. This would be her dream come true.
I have been the coordinator for a playgroup in Stoke that caters to preschool children & their whanau that have health needs, developmental delays & disabilities. For over 20 years I have worked with hundreds of families…It is my personal, extensive experience with these families that lead me to become involved with this project.
I am happy to present this submission to council. I am keen to be further involved in this project & as we are in Saxtons field daily then I am sure I will become the unofficial guardian/rubbish collector on a long term basis.
As the Saxton complex is a joint venture I will also make a submission to TDC.
Kind regards
Nicki & Halena Berkett
887.34 Hana Wilkinson for National Public Health Service None NPHS Te Waipounamu fully supports development of an accessible
playground as mentioned on pg 37. It is understood that the project has
been discussed at community forums with key stakeholders (Blind Low
Vision New Zealand, Ministry of Disabled People and parents of
children with a disability). We recommend that they continue to be
consulted with throughout the project lifespan. Provision of a playground
that supports inclusive recreation should be prioritised so that Saxton
Field is considered a place of recreation for all abilities. The State of
Play report – Te Tau Ihu 2022 identified Playing and Playing on a
playground as the top two activities tamariki in Te Tauihu spend time
doing.6 We encourage the inclusion of play equipment that facilitates
and promotes active recreation providing for a diverse range of ages
and abilities. Accessible play equipment should be prioritised to provide
equity for all. A good example of an accessible playground is Magical
Bridge Claudelands Park, located near Hamilton.

It is understood that $20,000 every alternate year for accessibility
improvements has been allocated for across all Saxton Field facilities.
NPHS Te Waipounamu fully support this initiative to increase equity and
accessible sports infrastructure.

NPHS Te Waipounamu has been engaged in the discussions around
the future of Policy 4.8.2.3 of the Saxton Field Management Plan which
states – The advertising of alcohol shall not be permitted on Saxton
Field, apart from price and product schedules at point of sale. Council
took a courageous stance in 2021 to include this policy and to amend it
would be a backward step. Alcohol control polices which serve to limit
the users of reserves, including playgrounds, to exposure to alcohol
consumption, advertising and sponsorship can support young people.
Research shows that exposure to alcohol marketing for example, can
result in young people drinking earlier in their lives and drinking larger
amounts of alcohol.

As commented in our submission to TDCs 2021 LTP, NPHS Te
Waipounamu recommends that future reviews of reserves policies
include all of the alcohol control polices contained in the Saxton Field
Reserves management plan
Support development of an accessible playground.
Retain Policy 4.8.2.3 of the Saxton Field Management
Plan which states – The advertising of alcohol shall not
be permitted on Saxton Field, apart from price and
product schedules at point of sale.
1474.20 Fiona Ede for Nature and Climate Group, Nelson Tasman Climate Forum None Environment and Parks and Active Recreation:

undertake extensive analysis of the risks posed by climate change to indigenous biodiversity and ecosystems;
develop and implement effective strategies to mitigate these risks to ensure that indigenous biodiversity and ecosystems are thriving in the face of a rapidly changing climate;
mandate an 80% survival metric for plants at two years after planting in the Performance Measure table on page 90;
please also refer to our section on funding for weed control

Botanic Gardens

We also advocate an expansion of the Urban Greening Plan to include the development of a Botanic
Garden for the district, in conjunction with TDC, with a potential location in Saxton Fields.

Many New Zealand cities have Botanic Gardens, and one only needs look to Hamilton to see how effective
they can be as a tourism destination, an educational resource and a highly valuable amenity for all the
community.

We would like to see the absence of such an important resource for the Nelson/Tasman community
rectified. A key component would be the development of an indigenous biodiversity area, with other
benefits, including potentially research into the implications of climate change on our local flora and
fauna. The fantastic growing climate locally provides an excellent opportunity to develop a garden
complex, and could draw on the skills of the Horticulture department at NMIT in its planning and
development.
The development of Botanic Gardens locally will provide an education resource for the public, creating
greater understanding of the importance of different types of trees, shrubs and other flora, a relaxing and
pleasant recreational space for locals and tourists to improve their mental and physical well-being,
opportunities for building the further greening of Nelson City, and carbon sequestration.  
Building Community and Environmental Resilience

We urge Council to work with the community to build food security by resourcing and supporting the
development of more community gardens and garden allotments, and for householders to grow more
backyard produce and fruit trees. 
We recommend that Council expands its native plant nursery to develop a scheme to provide low-cost
indigenous plants to the Nelson community.
We urge Council to ensure that funding for improving park assets should also include increasing resourcing
for indigenous plantings. There is a wide range of research that confirms the increased mental wellbeing of
people when able to easily access trees and green spaces. Treed green spaces with accessible walkways
can improve the wellbeing of a wide range of people in our community – not just the fit and active, unlike
sports fields.
1147.6 Ayla Turner for Nelson Youth Council None Comment: All Weather Sports Turf
The Nelson Youth council supports the proposed approach on the all weather sports turf, and recognises the need for an all weather sports turf, accessible to the public in Nelson.
We support the funding going towards this project, as it caters towards various sports that require aforementioned turf, and strengthens the sporting infrastructure within Nelson.
We propose that the installation of the All Weather Sports Turf is installed in Saxton, Nelson, with the aim of improving the region’s sporting infrastructure. This initiative offers several benefits to both the community and it could potentially have both Nelson City Council and Tasman District Council involved.
One major advantage of all-weather sports turf is its reduced maintenance requirements
compared to traditional grass pitches. This turf eliminates the need for frequent mowing and watering, resulting in lower operational costs and reduced environmental impact. Additionally, it ensures consistent playing conditions regardless of weather, allowing for year-round use.
Another benefit is the potential to attract more tournaments and events to Nelson. The
high-quality facilities provided by all-weather sports turf can enhance the region's reputation and stimulate economic activity. Moreover, the turf's design prioritises player safety, minimising the risk of injuries and encouraging active participation in sports and recreational activities.
Saxton is an ideal location for this initiative due to its central position within the Nelson Tasman region. Serving as a hub for various sports facilities, including the cricket oval, stadiums, and outdoor courts, Saxton ensures accessibility to a wide range of sports enthusiasts throughout the region. Furthermore, the project presents an opportunity for collaboration between Nelson City Council and Tasman District Council. By pooling resources and expertise, both councils can maximise the benefits of the initiative for their respective regions.
In conclusion, the installation of all-weather sports turf in Saxton represents a strategic
investment in the region's future. It promotes active lifestyles, fosters community engagement, and enhances overall quality of life for residents.
1047.5 Anna Berthelsen Option one I consider that Nelson should not install an artificial turf sports field because of the embodied carbon emissions and the release of microplastics. Embodied carbonNelson needs to look for all opportunities to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions and certainly should not be adding new sources of emissions that are not essential. The report Council commissioned from RSL in May 2020 calculated the embodied carbon emissions of plastic turf: 29 kg of C02-e per square metre per year, compared to 1 kg for natural turf.  For a 10,000m2 field that is 290,000kg (290 tonnes) of C02 every year, the equivalent embodied carbon in 707m3 of concrete. Furthermore, artificial turf doesn’t sequester any carbon, whereas a natural grass field of that size will sequester over 7 tonnes of CO2. Installing an artificial turf will also create an expectation by the sports clubs that the turf will be replaced at the end of its life (typically only 8-10 years). The used turf will need to be disposed of in landfill (at high cost) while the new turf would generate still more embodied carbon emissions and microplastics into the environment. MicroplasticsPlastic turf releases microplastic particles into the air and water[5]. This generates runoff of microplastics into stormwater systems and the potential for inhalation by players and spectators. This has led the European Union and some other jurisdictions to ban some uses of microplastics in artificial turf[6]. These actions reflect rising concern about microplastics in every part of the environment, including our food. Two of NZ’s leading cancer researchers are seeking funding to investigate a potential link between microplastics and a documented rise in bowel cancer. Nelson should not be replacing natural turf with a plastic surface that will generate adverse effects on people and the environment for years to come.
115.2 Tarran and Chris Hartshorne and Laney None Saxtons Playground
It has come to our attention via a letter from a neighbour that an “inclusive Saxtons Playground” is being proposed nearby the Saxtons Pond at Saxtons field.
While we are in support of having another playground in the Saxtons area, we are strongly opposed the suggested position.
Reasons as follows.
Already, when events are held at Saxton people park on Daelyn drive on the corner where the park meets the road. It causes congestion and narrows the road to only being able to fit one travelling vehicle through. On a corner this is a hazard that could cause an accident. A playground in that area would likely encourage more people to do this.
Many people enjoy that small area to allow their dogs a place to walk or train away from the playing fields which is a great space.
A playground in that position is likely to cause complaints from parents/caregivers and limit those already using the area in a positive enjoyable manner.
We are already aware from living in the area that there is problem with youth that often hang around the Saxtons area in the hours of darkness. And, have had both our vehicles broken into losing close to 10k worth of property. We have concerns that having a playground close to the residential homes may encourage antisocial behaviour and increase crime rates by drawing people to the area close to the houses.
We really enjoy living in this area and the quiet peacefulness of this. A suggestion would be positioning one closer to the velodrome where there is ample parking and a place already made use by many families.  In addition to this it would be better accessed for security guards/police to monitor over night.
Another suggestion that may be more cost affective is to upgrade the existing playground closer to the netball courts.
Thankyou for the consideration of our views.
895.9 Gordon Shaw for Nelson Netball Centre Inc. None Nelson Netball Centre Inc. Long Term Plan Submission April 2024
Submission to: Nelson City Council
Subject: Funding Request for Feasibility Study on adding roof to outdoor Netball courts at Saxton Field  for Nelson Netball Centre.
Introduction
Nelson Netball Centre Inc. (NNC) respectfully submits this proposal to [Council Name] as part of the Long Term Plan (LTP) discussion, seeking an allocation of $55,000 in the next annual budget for conducting a feasibility study. This study aims to explore the potential of adding a roof to the outdoor netball courts at Saxton Field. In light of the LTP's allocation of $211,357 for the 26/27 outyear for court resurfacing, we propose a reallocation of some funds to the 24/25 fiscal year to facilitate this crucial study.
Supporting Information
Our submission is bolstered by a detailed slide pack, alongside emails of support from Sport Tasman, Netball Mainland and a letter from Visitor Solution Ltd. These documents collectively underscore the broad-based community and stakeholder endorsement of our initiative.
In conclusion, the Nelson Netball Centre Inc. appeals to [Council Name] for support in funding this essential feasibility study.
By doing so, we can collectively ensure that Saxton Field remains a beacon for sporting excellence and community engagement in the Nelson/Tasman region.
We look forward to your positive response and are available for any further discussions or clarifications required.
We wish to present on our submission.
Sincerely,
Gordon Shaw
Deputy Chair
Project Lead
Nelson Netball Centre Inc.
https://www.nelsonnetball.co.nz/
912.2 Matthew Jepson Option one I do not believe a new all-weather sports turf would significantly benefit any other club or entity, other than those already on site, based on the proposed locations (Neale Park or Saxton Field)I support improving lighting and quality of existing grass fields instead (Option 1 from 2021 review)Specific suggestions:Install new lighting along both sides of Tahunanui fields near modelers pondReplace poles with taller ones on main reserveConcerns that an all-weather turf would inevitably become focused on serving needs of co-located clubs like FC Nelson, Suburbs and schoolsAn all-weather turf may come at the expense of reduced maintenance for existing grass fields---‐---------Upgrading Tahunanui Reserve Facilities:Tahuna FC strongly supports upgrading facilities at Tahunanui ReserveCurrent amenities like changing rooms are extremely substandard - old, rundown, and leakingWith 6 senior teams and plans for a youth program, the club requires better facilitiesOpportunity to transform the reserve into an integrated community hub for summer and winter sport codesRequest for Tahuna FC to be included in any consultation on new shared facilities impacting operationsPropose exploring housing Tahuna FC in any new multi-code facility for surf lifesaving and summer sportsCould create operational efficiencies and reduce maintenance costsProvide a vibrant, sustainable community hub for year-round sport and recreationFacilities should match the world-class status of Tahunanui Beach environment
171.3 Richard Boodee Option one The council taskforce has recommended an approach that replaces a potential future income stream (albeit small) with a future stream of costs.  That may create some benefits for trampers and bush walkers who already have many options in the Nelson / Tasman region. It strikes me that the taskforce went in with a preconceived agenda and have merely chosen to justify that to the community. Given the funding pressures on the council adopting a new stream of costs appears inappropriate and at odds with the objective of balancing the needs of the community.   If the council bodies responsible for the commercial forests are unable to generate a profit from doing so then the council should firstly offer management rights to forestry companies who do have that ability.  At least then there will be some income to offset current and future rates increases.  If the council can't find companies who will pay for those forestry rights then there is a case for converting forest land to native forest.  However I am not aware that case has yet been made.  Even if it proves that all the rights can't be sold then surely there is capacity for the council to offer the rights for the more financially attractive forestry blocks with the remainder progressively converted to natives.  A staggered approach to converting away from commercial forestry would at least start balancing those additional costs with some income.
895.6 Gordon Shaw for Nelson Netball Centre Inc. None of the above Subject: Funding Request for Feasibility Study on adding roof to outdoor Netball courts at Saxton Field  for Nelson Netball Centre.NNC – Key Issue #6 – all-weather sports turf. IntroductionNelson Netball Centre Inc. (NNC) respectfully submits this proposal to [Council Name] as part of the Long Term Plan (LTP) discussion, seeking an allocation of $55,000 in the next annual budget for conducting a feasibility study. This study aims to explore the potential of adding a roof to the outdoor netball courts at Saxton Field. In light of the LTP's allocation of $211,357 for the 26/27 outyear for court resurfacing, we propose a reallocation of some funds to the 24/25 fiscal year to facilitate this crucial study.
762.2 Maureen Hodgson None Thank you for the opportunity to make a submission on behalf of the families who visit Saxton Field.

We have lived in the close vicinity to Saxton Field for a number of years.  During this time, we have taken our grandchildren over to enjoy this environment..
Unfortunately, during these visits we have been very aware of the lack of facilities for younger children and also play items that challenge slightly older children and also allow play for disabled and mobility challenged children.

There are so many other amazing spaces within this zone, and a playground of this type would certainly enhance the area and bring more families to enjoy the space,

We would love to see an area that can be utilized by children of all ages.

Yours Sincerely
Maureen Hodgson
1482.6 Lindsay Wood for Resilienz Ltd Option one We do not agree with the recommendation and favour option 1 (retain current approach).We consider there is insufficient data supplied to endorse the proposal, although we note the requirement that the clubs involved have some “skin in the game”.It is unclear in the LTP as to the extent of usage of the facility, or how bad a handicap the present arrangements are, and it appears that the area is primarily being developed as a training facility.At a time when there is significant pressure on rates and compelling reasons to apply funding in other areas, we oppose such investment in what is an unclear and possibly low-priority application.We are not averse to this being reconsidered in the next Annual Plan, with suitably expanded supporting data.
113.2 Geoffrey Scott None Saxtons inclusive play space
As a frequent user of some facilities at the SAXTONS RECREATIONAL AREA, which is a great asset for the District as a whole, I note the need to have a safe and proper place for disadvantaged persons to enjoy it too, which is currently lacking.
I understand funding is, or might be available, within the Councils organisation to establish such a place for wheelchair bound persons, those with limited mobility and young persons to enjoy the area too.
Accordingly as a Rate Payer I fully support the use of our finances to establish an environment where children, parents and those in need can safely play, observe and enjoy the outdoors.
112.2 Richard and Lynn Simmons None Saxtons inclusive Play Space
WE FULLY SUPPORT THIS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & A PLAY SPACE LIKE THIS IS DEARLY NEEDED FOR OUR CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE OF ALL ABILITIES,  TO HAVE A SUITABLE PLACE  TO SAFELY PLAY AND ENJOY.
SAXTON FIELDS & WALKWAYS ARE ENJOYED DAILY BY SO MANY AND A PLACE LIKE THIS WILL BE AN AWESOME ADDITION FOR WHEELCHAIR USERS, WHO WOULD BENEFIT FROM HAVING A PLAY SPACE THAT THEY CAN ACCESS WITH EASE
41.2 Rochelle Cross None I wish to put in a submission in support of the Inclusive Play Space at Saxton Field.  We live nearby and feel this would be a wonderful asset to the Saxton Area as at the moment that space is really only used by people walking dogs.  I believe it would make the area safer and more pleasant for everyone as it would discourage boy racers doing burnouts in the carpark if it is frequented by families during the day.
It would be lovely for kids of all ages and abilities to have a safe place to play and for their families to come together.
32.2 Alisa and Steve Duncan None We would like to support the submission for an inclusive playground at Saxtons.
There are a lot of families in this area and there is not a play space in close enough proximity to the Daelyn Drive area.
It would be awesome to have a play space in this area for our community and would strengthen the connections and allow a fun space for the kids from our area to play.
Having accessible equipment would be great as there is not a play space for those in wheelchairs anywhere near us.
Thank yhou for including this in your plan.
1433.6 Jacinda Stevenson for Tahunanui Business and Community Association Option two All-weather Sports TurfTBCA supports Option 2 – construct an all-weather turf and reduce the current upgrade programme An all-weather sports turf would make Nelson an attractive destination for sports tournaments and national events as well as providing an alternative playing and training venue for sports codes in wet conditions. Siting it somewhere centrally (Saxton Field?) would allow it to benefit from existing infrastructure, which could help reduce costs.
33.2 Anna Wallace None Just a quick note to say our family is hugely in support of an inclusive play space at Saxton field.
We have a 3 year old and 1 year old twins, one of whom has cerebral palsy.  To have a place they could all play together, as well as with cousins and friends would be amazing.  Otherwise she will end up on the sideline like she will with so many other things.
Kind regards
116.2 Julie Coutts None Saxtons Inclusive Play Space
To all involved
I believe that NCC has allocated funding in the Draft Long Term Plan to build an inclusive play space at Saxton Fields.
As someone who works side by side with people who have disabilities, I fully support this community development.  A centrally accessed space for people of all abilities to enjoy is much needed, and long overdue.
 Thank you for accepting my submission.
682.6 Marie Sweet Option two Saxton is such an amazing complex.  Investing in an all weather turf would be fantastic for our community. I think this is only the start though and it shouldn't be at the detriment to the other pitches.  Tamariki need good pitches to train on.  I'd rather see cuts in other areas to support this proposal as it is used my a high number of our community.
90.2 Tiana MacEwan None I'm an writing in support of the inclusive saxtons playground. My daughter attends a group called little stars for children with development delays and disabilities where I heard about this proposal NCC is considering. Having a safe space available for wheelchair users, walkers and pushchairs would be appreciated by many and I would love to take my daughter to a playground like this if it were built.
1072.6 Gaire Thompson Option one Alarge amount was spent on the turf at Trafalgar Park and facilities at Saxtons Field at little or no cost to the sports involved whereas the Aero Club are charged commercial rates for ground rental rates and landing fees when the western grass would be sufficient for them as their park. They do not run a commercial operation , just a sporting club that help establish the current air port.
1489.7 Simon Campbell Option two This needs to happen - this would be a great investment in the community it is one of the biggest attractions in the nelson and the facilities could be world class - this would be a better investment and use of money that the whole region would benefit from - the huge amount of money wasted on - maintaining the churches in the region - bike parks - reporting with no action is mind blowing
187.2 Lesley and Nick Ashwell None Hi there,
I would like to add my support for an inclusive playground at Saxton Field. I think this would be a fantastic place for all children to play in and as there is already funding allocated as part of the Draft Long Term Plan then the sooner it is started the better. This would mean so much to anyone in a wheelchair to be able to join in.
50.2 Barbara Hayes None Inclusive Saxtons Playground
I wish to forward my submission fully supporting the development of a play space for our children and young people of all abilities with an emphasis on provision of facilities for wheelchair users, walkers and pushchairs. This would allow children in our region who are challenged by inadequate access to playgrounds to finally be able to use a playground alongside their friends.
154.11 Cassandra Thomson None I would like to see an Inclusive Play Space at Saxton's between the Saxton Pond and the Saxton Oval.  The would be great for children and young adults of all abilities to enjoy.  Saxton fields walkways are enjoyed daily by so many and a place like this will enhance the environment and be an awesome addition to our community.
274.6 Shane Bond Option two in my opinion having the all weather turf at Saxton would be the most cost efficient given that there are already flood lights installed which will cut down on cost. Also with with existing public toilets and the hockey turf makes for a great economical boost for Nelson, by allowing us and giving our young community great opportunities to host sport tournament all year round.
117.2 Geoff and Lynn Woodman None Saxtons inclusive play space
Hello Team,
We would like to add our support to the proposed play space at Saxton field. We think its an excellent idea ,we live close by and often take our grandkids over there and have found it to be a safe environment for all ages.
31.2 Brent and Sue Colvin None We fully support an inclusive Play Space at Saxtons as there is no playground in the Champion Road to Saxton area and also making it an inclusive playground would be great.